Experience the Artistry of Our Open Kitchen
Experience the culinary expertise at Lucia’s Italian Kitchen, where our skilled chefs meticulously prepare exquisite dishes in our open kitchen, delivering a truly remarkable dining experience.
Minimal Ingredients… Maximum Flavor
Minimal ingredients require the highest quality of ingredients. We source from local farmers to the world’s best durum wheat flour in Italy, to partnering with the finest cheese company in the US. Our ingredients are the lifeblood of our restaurant.
Meet the Chef
Taking pride in creating a memorable experience for all our guests.
Our Founder
Geno McWilliams
Established Lucia’s Italian Kitchen in 2020. By perfecting traditional pizza and handmade pasta recipes, coupled with some innovative tweaks, he has transformed Lucia’s into destination dining experience in the heartland of America.
Customer Testimonials
We value every customer’s dining experience!
We shared a garden salad, deconstructed grilled cheese, carbonara, pepperoni pizza with hot honey and the chocolate cake. All was magnifico. We will definitely be back.
Trisha Kiwior
October 25, 2025
Absolutely loved the food…Alfredo was heavenly. Girls at the reception are really helpful. Will surely visit again when in Effingham.
Syed
October 9, 2025
We ordered pizzas, but they only come in 1 size and are pretty expensive for what you get. The food was good and servers were nice. Not a lot of options though and prices are high.
Jennifer Matthews
October 5, 2025
Amazing Food!
Tamara Martin
October 4, 2025
A lovely little gem! The atmosphere was pleasant and the staff were very helpful! Lastly, the food was delicious!! Highly recommend a visit even if you’re just passing through town!
Erin A
September 26, 2025
Food was amazing we had the pizza and Ceasar salad the home made sauces for the pizza and salad were so rich, so flavorful. The chef was so friendly and explained the roots of the restaurant. It was a great experience and amazing food.
L.J. Goheen
September 19, 2025
4.6 FROM OVER465 REVIEWS
Frequently asked questions.
No, Lucia’s Italian Kitchen does not sell alcohol. However, we welcome patrons to bring their own beverages (BYOB) to complement their dining experience. Feel free to bring your favorite wine or beverage of choice to enjoy with our exquisite Italian dishes.
Yes, Lucia’s Italian Kitchen is committed to catering to diverse dietary needs. We provide a range of gluten-free options to ensure that all our guests can savor the flavors of Italian cuisine without compromising their dietary preferences or restrictions. Our gluten-free menu includes carefully crafted dishes made with the same dedication to quality and taste.
No, reservations are not accepted at Lucia’s Italian Kitchen. We operate on a first-come, first-served basis to provide an inclusive and efficient dining experience for all our guests. Rest assured, our attentive staff will do their best to accommodate you promptly, ensuring a delightful dining experience without the need for advance bookings.
No, Lucia’s Italian Kitchen currently does not offer delivery services. However, we invite you to join us in our charming establishment to experience the full ambiance and quality of our dishes. Our focus is on providing an exceptional in-house dining experience that goes beyond the convenience of delivery.
Yes, for those who prefer to enjoy our culinary creations in the comfort of their own space, Lucia’s Italian Kitchen offers a convenient takeout option. Simply place your order, and our dedicated team will ensure that your carefully packaged Italian delights are ready for pick-up, allowing you to relish the flavors of Lucia’s at your convenience.
Experience A Taste Of Italy At Lucia’s
Every visit to Lucia’s Italian Kitchen promises to be a memorable occasion for you and your loved ones.
